top of page

Elsinore (A PopEntertainment.com Movie Review)

Writer: PopEntertainment
PopEntertainment
2 minutes ago
4 min read
Elsinore
Elsinore

ELSINORE (2026)


Starring Andrew Scott, Olivia Colman, Billie Piper, Johnny Flynn, Luke Thompson, David Dawson, Matthew Beard, Joe Locke, Juliet Stevenson, Peter Mullan, Louis Healy, Dickie Beau, Kadiff Kirwan, Georgie Glen, Danny Webb, Jamie Bogyo, Alyth Rosst, David Rintoul, Malcolm Jeffries, John Hollingworth, Rishi Rian, Adeel Akhtar and Ronkẹ Adékoluẹjo.


Screenplay by Stephen Beresford.


Directed by Simon Stone.


Distributed by Focus Features. 111 minutes. Rated R.


Screened at the 2026 Philadelphia Film Festival.


It would not be unusual upon hearing the premise of Elsinore to fear that it may be depressing as hell. It is a based-on-a-true-story drama about a gay actor in the 1980s who finally won the chance at his dream role, playing Hamlet at the National Theater in London, right as he learned that he had AIDS. Therefore, despite his grave illness, he decides the show must go on and drags himself out onstage to give the performances of his life.


And, yes, in many ways it is a depressing story. However, it is surprising how funny and life-affirming Elsinore can be while telling such a tragic tale. (And if you’re wondering about the title, Elsinore is the name of the castle in Hamlet.)


Elsinore is based on the story of British actor Ian Charleson (played by Andrew Scott). Charleson looked to be a talent on the rise when his first starring role in a film was a low-profile British historical drama about a couple of athletes in the 1924 Paris Summer Olympics called Chariots of Fire, which surprisingly became a success and won the Oscar for Best Picture in 1982. However, as is pointed out almost as a running gag throughout Elsinore, which takes place in 1989, less than a decade later Chariots of Fire was mostly remembered for the hit synthesizer-based theme song by new age musician Vangelis if the film was remembered at all.


Charleson’s big follow-up role never quite materialized. He was still going on auditions for everything from cheesy police shows to commercials. He was happily out to his friends and coworkers – although some of his gay actor friends gave him a hard time for playing straight roles. The debate feels surprisingly contemporary, and it’s hard not to wonder if the film is projecting modern conversations about representation onto 1989.


It is also in the midst of the AIDS pandemic. Charleson has seen many of his friends succumb to the disease. He is HIV+ himself, and he obsessively goes to doctors and looks all over his body for sores and signs of the condition becoming full-blown AIDS.

Charleson’s big chance at playing the Dane came when the original star of the production – film star Daniel Day-Lewis – suddenly walked offstage in the middle of a performance, never to return (to Hamlet, or eventually stage acting). The film never really explains why Day-Lewis quit so suddenly, which would seem to be a fascinating story. It also never quite tells you whether the production continued in the weeks that it took to get Charleson ready to play the role.


As it turns out, Day-Lewis had a nervous breakdown due to the strain from doing the intense part for eight months, and Jeremy Northam played the role for five weeks while Charleson was being hired and prepared for the part. These feel like the kind of revelations that could have been conveyed in a line or two of dialogue to make the chronology of the story easier to follow.


Of course, in one of Charleson’s first rehearsals, the makeup artist found he had grown a small skin lesion on his face. She assumed it was nothing, but being HIV+ and having so many sick friends, Charleson knew the probable relevance of that sore. He went to his doctor, who said the AIDS was progressing.


Charleson was referred to a prestigious doctor, Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman), who felt she could treat him and give him extra time, but he would have to quit the play – which was way too much strain and pressure for the man as he was fighting for his life.

But if he took her advice, there wouldn’t have been a movie, would there?


The film rises and falls upon the performance of Scott, and he delivers one of the best performances of the year. In fact, he pretty much single-handedly raises Elsinore up from perhaps being slightly melodramatic into something truly authentic and moving. Scott obviously relates strongly to Charleson, both as a long-struggling actor and as a gay man. He approaches the character with a sense of authenticity and humanity, and yet he does not wallow in the darkness. His Charleson is funny and vivid and full of life. A fellow of infinite jest, of most excellent fancy, even when his body is failing him.


Billie Piper and Johnny Flynn were quite good in their roles as his supportive best friend and the producer who casts him; it's just they weren't given much to do that anyone couldn't have done. The only real disappointment is Olivia Colman’s doctor. Colman’s portrayal was probably a character choice; her doctor seemed a bit uptight and humorless and the portrayal represented that.


With a slightly odd filmmaking choice by director Stone and screenwriter Beresford, the film plays much of the last half hour in montage shots, flipping back and forth between times and places. It can be very touching and make certain connections between characters and plot points. At the same time, the staccato cutting can drain some of the darker moments of the power they would have had if the film had just allowed the moment to breathe. And sadly, many of Scott’s performances of scenes from Hamlet get caught up in those montages, as well, giving us only snippets of classic moments.


The first hour or so was a lot less choppy, a lot funnier (sometimes gallows humor, sometimes just character stuff from smart, snappy people) and necessarily more enjoyable than the dark turns of the climax. The film captures its era well and looks at the AIDS epidemic with knowing empathy, bringing back the dark days when the epidemic was running roughshod through entire communities.


While Elsinore has its stumbles, Scott’s performance alone makes it worth seeing. As Hamlet himself intoned, “The readiness is all.” 


Jay S. Jacobs


Copyright ©2026 PopEntertainment.com. All rights reserved. Posted: November 19, 2026.



Comments


bottom of page